They do opposite things
Wim Hof-style breathing (Auralize\'s Power Breathing) activates. Blood pH shifts, catecholamines release, arousal rises, warmth increases. Slow breathing (coherence 5.5-5.5) downshifts. Vagal tone rises, HRV amplitude peaks, arousal falls. These are opposite directions on the autonomic map.
Different training targets
Wim Hof targets interoceptive capacity, cold tolerance, immune response, adrenaline-mediated alertness. Slow breathing targets HRV, blood pressure, resting arousal, vagal tone. There is essentially no overlap in what they change.
Can you do both
Yes, and most experienced practitioners do. Power breathing three mornings a week; coherence every evening. Different tools for different targets. The mistake is treating them as interchangeable or as competitors — they are neither.
Which to start with
Slow breathing. Almost always. It has fewer contraindications, is safer to practice unsupervised, and provides a foundation of nervous-system training that makes power breathing safer and more productive when you get there. Six weeks of coherence before your first Power Breathing round is a reasonable onramp.